Project Analysis
Project Goal
Our project aims to compile different perspectives of people within the hierarchy of the Georgia Gwinnett College (GGC) community and their experiences during the onset of COVID-19. Compiling different perspectives within the hierarchy is important when gathering a full perspective of how COVID-19 impacted an individual community with individuals of diverse backgrounds. By focusing on the GGC community, we hope to gain further insight into how these different backgrounds may have impacted the response to changes brought by COVID-19.
Our leading research question for our project is “How did different subgroups respond based on their level of hierarchy at GGC.” The research question aims to document the varying levels of disruption that the COVID-19 pandemic has had on the GGC community and on the different levels of hierarchy.
We, the researchers heading this project, are qualified to investigate these experiences due to our active involvement in the GGC community. We are invested in the community through our classes, our on-campus jobs, the clubs we participate in, and our other engagements on campus. Therefore, we are most qualified to investigate how COVID-19 impacted the community we have spent ample time in.
In the leading research topic, there were several questions that needed to be considered as part of the overall project goal:
“How did different subgroups at GGC respond to the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic based on their hierarchy?”
“How effective were different levels of GGC administration and faculty at operating during the COVID-19 pandemic?”
“How effective were GGC students at pursuing their education during the COVID-19 pandemic?”
“How did each subgroup manage emotionally during the COVID-19 pandemic?”
“Were there shared struggles between subgroups? If so, what were the shared struggles that each subgroup faced during the COVID-19 pandemic?
“Were there unique struggles experienced by different subgroups? If so, how did they compare to each other?”
Methodology
We, the researchers, divided the hierarchy into four sub-groups: administrators, professors, staff, and students. Each researcher was in charge of a particular sub-group. Within these groups, we sought to include individuals of different ethnic backgrounds, genders, and academic focus areas. We collected biographical information from our participants through the use of a questionnaire. We also asked our participants to send over their most recent resumes so that we could gain even more insight about their educational and work backgrounds. We, the researchers, then established a list of eleven questions to be used in our interviews so that there was consistency throughout all of our interviews. The list of questions acted as a guiding point for analysis and continuity between the interviews.
After asking the questions from our list, we would then ask other questions based on who we were interviewing. The resume and questionnaire were useful since we were able to form questions based on the information they gave us.
Before we interviewed our participants, we required that they sign a release form in order for us to have permission to use their interviews for our project and any other projects that would come out of this website.
Finally, after we conducted our interviews, we worked on transcribing our interviews and edited for grammar and sentence flow.
The files below link to the questionnaire and release form that we used with our participants:
Challenges
Throughout the project, we, the researchers, faced challenges in finding participants to interview. With issues related to the pandemic, such as mask and vaccine mandates, being points of tension within some departments, there were some individuals hesitant to participate in recorded interviews. Some professors were afraid to speak their minds since they feared their views would not be accepted by those around them. In addition, we found it hard to communicate efficiently with students in order to secure a meeting time for interviews. As a result, there are fewer student perspectives showcased. Some students were willing to participate but never responded when deciding on a time and place to meet.
The participants we were able to secure interviews with, however, were excellent and effectively communicated when we reached out to them. Another challenge we faced was the amount of time needed to conduct the project, which is why we have a small sample size. Since the project was conducted within the span of one semester (approximately 14 weeks), we were only able to collect a small percentage of those who were at GGC during the COVID-19 pandemic. Therefore, it is impossible for official conclusions and themes to be drawn given our small number of interviews. The pandemic is still ongoing, so whatever conclusions and themes we did decide on would most likely not be the same conclusions a year or more later. The participants we were able to get interviews with shared a lot of information, and we are thankful for the insights they provided us.
Conclusions
Due to each individual facing unique circumstances, it is difficult to correlate common themes within the hierarchies. Within each level, there is still a wide array of differences based on background and interpretations of the pandemic. There are, however, some themes that can be taken away from the interviews.
With the college administrators, they were primarily untouched during the worst of the pandemic. Provost Low was able to move from California to Georgia when he changed jobs. Likewise, Dean Winterhalter also had to relocate within the state of Georgia when she started working at Georgia Gwinnett College. Since they were both able to move, there is no sign of financial difficulties. Given their positions as provost and dean, it is safe to assume they both make a decent income. They were both able to work from home, so they could continue their jobs without question. However, their own professors, staff, and students did not have that luxury and were at times forced to return to campus and in-person classes before they were ready. Even if the provost and dean had to come to campus, they both had spacious offices that would keep them socially distanced from others and safe from exposure to people who might be sick.
However, both Dean Winterhalter and Provost Low expressed sympathy for those who are in classrooms teaching or studying and are forced to be around others who may not be vaccinated or even care to wear a mask. They both try to support the faculty and students whenever they have the opportunity to do so. Since they both came into their positions during the time GGC was online, they do feel disconnected from campus life and would like to interact with the students more than they have been able to. They both expressed that they enjoy staying active, so when gyms closed because of the pandemic, they had to find ways to safely workout inside and outside their homes.
The professors faced challenges based on their academic disciplines and their other responsibilities. For example, as a chemistry professor, Dr. Bell faced the challenge of transitioning both lectures and labs online. The challenge with moving labs online is the hands-on component and the equipment used. In contrast, Dr. Ackerson, as a history professor, only had to transition to lecture classes online. Although the preference may have been to have in-person interactions, the transition was less complicated than in the sciences. The professors in the roles of the chairs of the departments also faced unique challenges. Dr. Bell, Dr. Edwards, and Dr. Jamaloodeen mention their responsibilities in forming plans to move classes online and the added pressure this caused. Although they understood the added work was necessary, the limited amount of time given posed a challenge.
In addition, with GGC being a primarily in-person campus prior to the pandemic, the expected knowledge of technology added a learning curve for professors across the disciplines. Dr. Jamaloodeen makes references to the crash course in technology many professors had during the two-week shutdown. Dr. Bell also discusses the evolution of technology used throughout online learning, as the professors used trial and error to figure out the best teaching practices. Furthermore, Dr. Edwards points out the challenges of minimizing isolation with the online format. The professors each faced their own unique challenges based on their personal backgrounds and academic focus areas. Despite these differences, there are some commonalities based on their roles.
The students interviewed during this project expressed challenges in transitioning to online classes but maintained academic success. Both Patel and Jamaloodeen refer to the lack of use of video cameras and the disconnect that caused. Patel elaborates on how she was more hesitant to ask questions due to her inability to see others’ reactions. Jamaloodeen expresses how, when returning to in-person interactions, his former professors did not know who he was because they had never seen his face in online classes. Despite the disconnect created by online classes, both Patel and Jamaloodeen maintained success in their classes. Patel has maintained a 4.0 GPA, and Jamaloodeen expressed how he did well in classes due to the understanding of his professors.
However, not all students were successful in the transition online. Dr. Bell and Dr. Edwards refer to students and how some struggled as a result of the pandemic. Dr. Bell discusses the increase in the withdrawal rate and failure rate for some courses. She also references personal conversations with students who were struggling in her course due to the online format. Dr. Edwards mentions the mental health implications that online learning has for students as a result of isolation. The transition to online learning posed numerous challenges, and although some students maintained their academic status, others struggled with the transition.